Skip to content

Resource · Union and labor law

Union crews and location tracking: bargaining before you deploy

For union crews, treat any new tracking or timekeeping device as something to bargain over before it is worn. Sections 8(a)(5) and 8(d) of the National Labor Relations Act require employers to bargain in good faith over wages, hours and other terms and conditions. NLRB General Counsel memo GC 23-02 on electronic monitoring was rescinded in 2025, but the statute and the duty did not change.

Last updated By ZeroBadge

This is general information, not legal advice. Laws differ by state and change over time. Check the primary sources below and talk to an employment lawyer about your situation.

Does the NLRA require you to bargain before deploying location tracking?

In most union settings the safe answer is yes, and you should plan on it. Section 8(a)(5) of the National Labor Relations Act makes it an unfair labor practice for an employer "to refuse to bargain collectively with the representatives of his employees," and section 8(d) defines that duty as meeting at reasonable times and conferring in good faith about "wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment" (29 U.S.C. 158).

The NLRB's own guidance says an employer may not "fail to bargain in good faith concerning mandatory subjects of bargaining," and that changes to wages, hours or working conditions generally have to wait until bargaining reaches agreement or an overall impasse (NLRB). A device that decides when paid time starts and stops, and that records where a member was during it, sits close to hours and conditions. The 8(d) duty also does not force either side to accept a proposal or make a concession, so bargaining is a process, not a veto.

What did NLRB GC 25-05 change about electronic monitoring?

It withdrew an enforcement priority, not the law. On February 14, 2025, Acting General Counsel William B. Cowen issued GC 25-05, which lists GC 23-02, the earlier memo on electronic monitoring, among several rescinded General Counsel memoranda.

A General Counsel memo tells regional offices how to approach cases. It is not a statute and not a Board decision. Rescinding GC 23-02 means the office is no longer directing regions to scrutinize electronic monitoring the way that memo urged. The section 8(a)(5) and 8(d) duty to bargain over mandatory subjects is in the statute and was untouched. A union can still file a charge about a unilateral change, and a future General Counsel can take a different view. Do not read the rescission as permission to skip bargaining.

What should you review in the CBA before you deploy anything?

Start with the articles that already govern how time is kept and what you may do unilaterally, because the agreement may answer the question before the law does. Ask counsel to read these together, not one at a time.

  • Management-rights clause: does it mention technology, timekeeping methods or electronic devices, or does it only say you direct the workforce.
  • Hours, reporting point and show-up pay: does the badge change when paid time begins, even slightly.
  • Travel, mileage and subsistence: do any of these depend on where a member is, or when.
  • Timekeeping and records article: who keeps the official record, and can a member dispute it.
  • Discipline and just-cause language: could badge data be used as evidence, and under what steps.
  • Remittance and reporting: do hours reported to benefit funds come from the same records.
  • Zipper or entire-agreement clause: does it limit adding terms mid-agreement.
  • Term and reopener: when does the agreement expire, and is there a window to propose new language.
  • Existing side letters or past practice on cameras, GPS in trucks, drug testing or other monitoring.
  • Any jurisdictional or multi-local language if crews travel between locals.

The reasoning for each of these, the information a union may request and an eight-week rollout plan are in union rules for employee tracking. This page stops at the checklist so the two do not duplicate each other.

How can verified clock-in data help union members?

It gives members a record that does not depend on a foreman's memory or a handwritten sheet. That is the argument most likely to land with a business agent, and it is worth making in good faith rather than as a sales line.

Where verified hours can help members, and the condition for each
Member concernHow verified data helpsWhat has to be true
Short pay on a disputed dayA timestamped record of when the shift started and ended is available to both sidesThe member can see and dispute their own record
Overtime proofHours across jobsites in one week add up from the same record, without a rounded paper totalOvertime rules in the agreement are applied to the record, not replaced by it
Travel between sitesTime on site and time in transit are separated, so a pay-rule discussion has factsThe agreement's travel rules still decide what is paid
Show-up and reporting payThe record shows when a worker reached the reporting pointThe reporting point is defined in the agreement, not by the badge
Benefit fund remittanceHours reported to funds can be reconciled against one sourceThe fund's own audit rules still control
These are possibilities, not outcomes. The same record can also be used against a member, which is why discipline and access language matters.

Be honest about the other edge. Verified data cuts both ways, and members know it. A union that sees tracking as a tool for catching lateness will say so. The credible reply is to agree in writing what the data will and will not be used for, and to give members access to their own records.

What can you say when you approach the business agent?

Keep it short, say what is not decided, and ask for the union's view before you commit. Here is a short script you can adapt. It is a sample for you and your counsel to edit, not required wording.

A short script for the first conversation (sample only)
You sayWhy it works
"I want to tell you about something I am considering before anyone wears it, and ask what you would want to see."It sets the order: you before the crews
"It is a company-owned badge. It records when a member's shift starts and ends and which jobsite they are at, during paid time only."Plain facts, no jargon, no overselling
"Each member would sign a written disclosure and consent, and could switch it off."Shows consent is separate and worker-controlled
"I have not decided how it fits the agreement. I would like to bargain over anything it affects."Acknowledges the duty rather than testing it
"What questions would your members ask first?"Invites the union to shape the terms
"I will send the description in writing, and I will not put it on a crew before we have talked."A commitment you can keep

Follow the call with a written notice and an offer to bargain, and ask counsel whether it should go through the local, a contractor association or both.

Where ZeroBadge fits

ZeroBadge is a company-owned cellular badge the worker wears at work. It is not the worker's phone, and nothing is installed on personal devices. It uses GPS, Wi-Fi positioning and cellular positioning, with a reading about every 5 minutes during scheduled work hours. Readings recorded outside scheduled hours are discarded automatically unless the worker is still clocked in for paid travel, workers can switch it off with one button, and it switches itself off at shift end.

Before a badge stores a worker's location, the worker reviews a plain-English disclosure in the worker portal and signs it electronically. That acknowledgment is supplemental. It does not replace the separate signed written consent ZeroBadge strongly recommends each employer obtain, which may be required by state or city law, or by a collective bargaining agreement, and is the employer's responsibility. A free sample consent template is available, for sample use only, for your attorney to review.

From the worker portal a member can see and download their data, dispute a time record, request deletion of raw location data and withdraw consent. Raw location is deleted after 30 days and time records are kept 4 years. Every acknowledgment, withdrawal and admin view of location detail is recorded in a timestamped, tamper-evident log. We verify work. We don't track people. ZeroBadge's tools support compliance. They don't make tracking legal by themselves.

Frequently asked questions

Can we pilot a badge with a few union members before we bargain?
A pilot on bargaining-unit members changes how their time is recorded, so raise it with the union first. Many unions will agree to a limited pilot with a steward involved and a review date. Ask counsel before you start.
Did GC 25-05 end the duty to bargain over monitoring?
No. GC 25-05 rescinded GC 23-02, a General Counsel memo. The duty comes from sections 8(a)(5) and 8(d) of the statute, which were not changed by the rescission. Whether a specific rollout must be bargained depends on your agreement and the facts.
Does prevailing wage or certified payroll change the analysis?
It adds a reporting need, not a different bargaining rule. Public works jobs often require reporting hours by worker, day and jobsite, so a union will care that the badge record matches what is reported. ZeroBadge aids certified payroll reporting by supplying verified hours by worker, day and jobsite. It does not produce or file certified payroll on its own; final certified payroll reports require review by a qualified person. See certified payroll explained.
Who has to sign the consent, the union or the worker?
The worker. A union can agree to terms for the bargaining unit, but individual written consent is a separate document that each worker signs, and obtaining it is the employer's responsibility.
What if the agreement says nothing about technology?
Silence usually means you should bargain rather than assume you may act alone, because a clear waiver of the union's right to bargain is the usual standard for acting without it. Ask labor counsel to confirm the current standard before deciding.
Can the union object to a badge but accept a phone app?
Either device changes how hours are recorded, so the bargaining question is similar. Unions often object more to a required personal phone, for cost and privacy reasons, than to company equipment. See badge vs. phone app compliance.

Sources

  1. 1.29 U.S.C. 158, National Labor Relations Act section 8 (subsections (a)(1), (a)(5) and (d)) · U.S. Code (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
  2. 2.Bargaining in good faith with employees' union representative (mandatory subjects, unilateral changes) · National Labor Relations Board
  3. 3.GC 25-05, Rescission of Certain General Counsel Memoranda (February 14, 2025) · National Labor Relations Board

Get started

See ZeroBadge on your workforce.

Tell us how your crews work today. We will show you a badge-recorded week built from your own jobsites.

What we will walk through

  • 01How the badge records a shift
  • 02Your jobsites as geofences
  • 03The weekly timesheet and approval
  • 04Sending approved hours to payroll